Is Blackjack Insurance Ever Worth It?
Blackjack insurance sounds like protection, but it is really a separate side bet with a house edge of about 7%. Here is the math, the truth about even money, and the one exception for card counters.
What Is Blackjack Insurance?
Blackjack insurance is a side bet offered when the dealer's upcard is an ace. Before the dealer checks for blackjack, you may put up to half your original bet on the insurance line. If the dealer turns out to have a ten-value card underneath, insurance pays 2:1. If not, you lose the insurance bet and the hand plays out normally.
The name is clever marketing. It sounds like you are protecting your main bet. In reality, insurance is a completely separate wager on one question: does the dealer have a ten in the hole? Your own hand has nothing to do with whether that bet wins.
Here is how a typical insured hand works with a 10-unit main bet and a 5-unit insurance bet:
- Dealer has blackjack: you lose the 10-unit main bet (unless you also have blackjack), but insurance wins 10 units. You break even.
- Dealer does not have blackjack: you lose the 5-unit insurance bet, and your main hand continues as usual.
Breaking even when the dealer has blackjack feels comforting. The question is what that comfort costs you over thousands of hands.
The Math: Why Insurance Is a Bad Bet
Insurance pays 2:1, so it only breaks even if the dealer's hole card is a ten exactly one time in three. Anything less, and the bet loses money in the long run.
Let's count. In a fresh six-deck shoe there are 312 cards, and 96 of them are ten-value (tens, jacks, queens, kings). With the dealer's ace removed, 311 unseen cards remain, 96 of them tens. That gives:
- Chance the hole card is a ten: 96 / 311 ≈ 30.9%
- Chance it is not: 215 / 311 ≈ 69.1%
Per unit bet, insurance returns +2 about 30.9% of the time and −1 about 69.1% of the time. That works out to roughly −7.4%. In other words, the house edge on insurance in a six-deck game is about 7%, compared with roughly 0.5% on the main game when you use basic strategy.
| Scenario (6 decks, dealer shows ace) | Probability | Insurance result per unit |
|---|---|---|
| Hole card is a ten | ≈30.9% | +2 |
| Hole card is not a ten | ≈69.1% | −1 |
| Break-even probability needed | 33.3% | 0 |
| Expected value | — | ≈ −0.074 |
A 7% house edge puts insurance among the worst bets on the table. Taking it every time an ace shows quietly multiplies what the game costs you.
Insurance doesn't care what you're holding, partner. Whether you've got a 20 or a 12, it's the same bet on the same hole card, and the odds stay the same. Just say "no insurance" and move on.
Does Your Hand Ever Make Insurance Better?
Many players insure only "good" hands like 19 or 20, figuring they have more to protect. It feels logical, but it doesn't change the math. The insurance bet wins or loses based only on the dealer's hole card.
Your cards matter in one small way: they are cards that are no longer in the shoe. If you hold two tens, there are slightly fewer tens left, so insurance is actually a little worse. If you hold small cards, it's slightly better, but in a multi-deck shoe that shift is far too small to overcome a 7% edge.
Holding a 20 made of two tens is one of the worst times to insure, even though it's the hand players most want to protect.
Even Money: Insurance in Disguise
When you have blackjack and the dealer shows an ace, the dealer will often ask if you want even money. Taking it means you get paid 1:1 right away, before the dealer checks for blackjack.
Even money is mathematically identical to insuring your blackjack. Say you bet 10 units:
- Insure with 5 units, dealer has blackjack: your blackjack pushes (0), insurance wins 10. Total: +10.
- Insure with 5 units, dealer has no blackjack: your blackjack wins 15 at 3:2, insurance loses 5. Total: +10.
Either way you win exactly 10, which is just even money. A guaranteed win sounds great, but declining it is worth more on average. Without even money, your blackjack wins 15 units about 69% of the time and pushes about 31% of the time, an average of roughly 10.4 units, more than the guaranteed 10.
Declining even money means that sometimes you'll watch the dealer flip a ten and push your blackjack. That stings, but over many hands the steady 3:2 payouts come out ahead.
The One Exception: Card Counters
Insurance becomes a good bet once the remaining shoe holds more than one ten for every two non-tens. Basic strategy players have no way to know when that happens. Card counters do.
In the Hi-Lo system, cards 2–6 count +1, 7–9 count 0 and tens and aces count −1. A high true count (running count divided by decks remaining) means the shoe is rich in tens. The well-known Hi-Lo index for insurance is a true count of +3 or higher: at that point there are enough tens left that insurance has a positive expected value.
| Player type | Insurance / even money decision |
|---|---|
| Basic strategy player | Never take it |
| Hi-Lo counter, true count below +3 | Decline |
| Hi-Lo counter, true count +3 or higher | Take it |
It is often called the single most valuable strategy deviation for counters, because it comes up whenever the dealer shows an ace in a ten-rich shoe. If you want to learn the steps, start with card counting for beginners and then running count vs true count.
Card counting is legal, but casinos are private businesses and can refuse to deal to a player they suspect of counting. Think of the counting exception as a skill to understand, not a way to beat the house.
Practice this hand in the free trainer
Tex shows the best move on every hand and explains why, so the chart sticks. Play money, no signup needed.
Why So Many Players Still Take Insurance
If the math is so clear, why is insurance so popular? A few reasons:
- The name. "Insurance" suggests the responsible choice. Nobody likes to be uninsured.
- Loss aversion. Losing a strong hand to a dealer blackjack feels worse than slowly paying a small edge, even when the slow cost is larger.
- Memory bias. You remember the times insurance saved you and forget the many small insurance bets you quietly lost.
- Dealer prompts. The dealer asks every time an ace shows, so it feels like a normal part of the game rather than an optional extra bet.
Taking insurance is one of the most common blackjack mistakes beginners make, right alongside the belief that you're "due" for a dealer ten. That second idea is a myth too, as covered in blackjack myths busted.
Next time the dealer flashes an ace, wave it off and play your hand by the chart. Practice that habit in a free blackjack trainer with play money until saying no feels automatic.
Bottom Line: Is Insurance Ever Worth It?
For nearly every player, the answer is no. Insurance is a side bet with a house edge of about 7% in a six-deck shoe, and even money is the same bet with a friendlier name. Your hand doesn't change that, and insuring a pair of tens is slightly worse than average.
The only exception is a skilled card counter with a Hi-Lo true count of +3 or more. For everyone else:
- Decline insurance every time.
- Decline even money on your blackjacks.
- Put your energy into basic strategy, where the real value is.
Remember that blackjack keeps a house edge even with perfect play. The goal of good strategy is to lose less, not to guarantee wins. Sharpen your decisions risk-free in the free blackjack trainer, which uses play money only.
Frequently asked questions
Should I take insurance in blackjack?
No, not if you play basic strategy. Insurance pays 2:1 but the dealer has a ten in the hole only about 31% of the time in a six-deck shoe, giving the bet a house edge of about 7%.
Is even money the same as insurance?
Yes. Taking even money on your blackjack produces exactly the same result as insuring it, so it carries the same negative expectation. Declining it earns more on average.
When do card counters take insurance?
Hi-Lo counters typically take insurance at a true count of +3 or higher, when the remaining shoe holds enough ten-value cards for the bet to have a positive expected value.
Should I insure a strong hand like 20?
No. Insurance wins or loses based only on the dealer's hole card, not your hand. A 20 made of two tens is actually slightly worse to insure, because it removes two tens from the shoe.
Keep reading
This guide is for education and entertainment. Blackjack has a house edge, and no strategy can guarantee winnings. Practice risk-free with play money in the Tex Blackjack trainer.